Mindset and the Markets, Episode 1: Where your mindset IS the edge.
Episode one is officially in the books, and I couldn't have asked for a better first guest.
I met Diana Perkins at Stocktoberfest about a month and a half ago, and we totally vibed on the markets and the mindset and psychology side of trading. Considering how choppy this market has been, it felt like the right time to get this show going. Diana has been on both sides of this game, as a professional options trader on a prop desk and now as a coach to hundreds of traders. Here's what stuck with me most from our conversation.
Most traders have a plan. Few follow it.
I asked Diana what she sees most often in the traders she works with. Her answer wasn't about setups or indicators:
"Most of the traders I work with have a trading plan strategy, but many lack the discipline to follow that strategy consistently in the market."
She put it in a way I really liked: "I always say the markets move on greed and fear. It's almost organized chaos."
The plan usually looks great before you're in the trade. Then there's money on the line. The trade moves your way and you're scared to give back the gains, so you get out early. Or it moves against you, you tell yourself "it'll come back," and you end up taking a loss twice the size you planned. Her point is that without a repeatable process you actually trust, those emotions take over once you're in.
She also called out the noise: the pundits, the people who've had success and seem worth copying, and the new hot thing that isn't in your plan but that you want to "just dabble" in. Every one of those is a chance to drift.
For me it's never really been about honoring stops. My battle has been cutting winners short, and getting chopped up when the market goes sideways. We all have our own thumbscrew. The work is figuring out what yours is.
A process you can repeat
Diana walked through her own process, and it's a great example of keeping things simple:
- Sunday is the work day. Before the market opens she scans the broad market (S&P, NASDAQ, Dow) and asks whether it's trending, choppy, or losing ground.
- Sectors next. She checks the 11 sector ETFs against the broad market and picks the two or three relatively strong ones.
- Then a watch list. She filters for individual names in those sectors, then watches for tradable patterns like a high base or a pullback during the week.
- Risk is set before entry. About 95% of her trades are defined-risk options spreads, sized to max loss, usually held for four to five weeks.
She's followed that core plan for nearly 15 years. The one big change she made early on was trading both weekly and monthly options so she could stagger her trades through the month while keeping her total risk the same. The plan itself didn't change. She just made it easier to execute.
Her own weak spot? Revenge trading. She doesn't like taking a loss and wants to get right back in. I appreciated her saying that. Even after 15 years, everyone has something to keep in check.
Confidence comes from experience, not prediction
We talked about process over prediction and where confidence actually comes from. For me, it comes from knowing there's always going to be another opportunity. Once you really believe that, you stop feeling like you have to size up on any one trade.
Diana tied that to something her dad taught her at the pool table: "There's always a shot on the table." She also said something every newer trader should hear: "There's no substitute for experience in the markets." Backtesting and paper trading are great, but confidence really builds once trading becomes almost mechanical, when you can sit through a string of losses because you already know how you'll respond.
Patience is a position
With all the headline risk out there (inflation reports, interest rates, sector rotation), Diana said a lot of her more experienced traders are sitting at least partly in cash right now:
"I always say patience is a position... I think it's just as important to know when to stay out of the market as it is when you're in the market."
That lines up with how I see this market. If we've been in a range for 8 to 12 weeks and price is below every major moving average, a long-side breakout trader has very little reason to force anything. The upside is that whatever comes out of a long base can be big. Lots of charts get rebuilt, and that's exciting if you're patient enough to wait for it.
Know your exits before you enter
On timing, Diana was blunt: it's one of the hardest things to do in the market, and it gets harder when you move from stocks to options because options have an end date. Her answer from a mindset point of view is to know your exits before you ever enter. Know where your target is, what you'll do when you hit it, and whether you'll take half off or trail a stop.
When we got into risk management, she explained how adjusting can still be disciplined. If volatility goes up and you widen your stop, you trade fewer shares so your risk stays the same. Her mentor used to tell her, "We're traders, we're nimble." Adjusting to conditions is fine. Just make sure your downside is protected.
Data is king
Near the end, Diana asked me if I'm journaling. Honest answer: I got away from it for a long time because I'd beat myself up over every trade that went from green to red. Her response was the nudge I needed:
"Process is important, but data is king, which I know is very nerdy, but it's true."
Her own journal showed her she was winning far more often on vertical spreads than on two-week diagonal spreads, and that she was forcing bearish trades in a bull market just to feel balanced. The data told her what to cut. I already know what my trade sheets would tell me, and that's exactly why I need to look.
The takeaway
Whether you're a long-term investor or an active trader, your edge isn't another indicator. It's how well you can follow your own process when there's money on the line. That's the whole point of this show: your mindset IS the edge.
About Diana Perkins, CPA
Diana Perkins is the Founder & CEO of Trading with Diana. She's a CPA with a background in auditing, technology product management and management consulting, and she spent years as a professional options trader in prop trading, where she worked with hundreds of traders. Today she coaches retail traders and investors, from people placing their very first trade to aspiring professionals, on strategy, risk management and the mindset to execute consistently.
Connect with Diana:
- Website: tradingwithdiana.com
- Free trading newsletter: tradingwithdiana.com/newsletter
- Trading Edge (weekly market outlook & trade setups): tradingwithdiana.com/edge
- X: @tradingwdiana
- Instagram: @tradingwithdiana
- Facebook: @tradingwithdiana
- LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/dianaperkinscpa
Watch the full episode
There's a lot more in the full conversation, including Diana's plain-English breakdown of the options Greeks and why a 95% win rate can still wipe out an account.
New episodes of Mindset and the Markets drop Mondays. Thanks for being here from the start.
Nick